Future of our public services

Michael Trickey, Director of the Wales Public Services 2025 programme, discusses the pressures facing public services in Wales ahead of the publication of two new reports.

The First Ministers’s announcement of a Commission on Public Service Governance and Delivery provides a welcome opportunity to look at the future of our public services. Beyond questions of the number of local authorities and the immediate pressures on the NHS looms an even bigger issue. Long-term financial projections, changes in population and other pressures mean that public services as we know them now may no longer be affordable or what is needed over the next 10 – 15 years. They will have to look and feel very different. In responding to this challenge, there is the chance for Wales to seize the opportunity in a way which is distinctive and transformative – but the momentum has to build now.

The issues are well-known. The squeeze on public spending is already biting. The Welsh Government’s budget will reduce significantly next year with the UK Coalition Government’s austerity programme extending to 2018 at least.

At the same time, service pressures are growing. Improved life expectancy is a cause for celebration but also means heavier demand for health and social care. Costs of providing care, new treatments and medical technology are rising. These pressures can be seen now and are expected to grow. The Kings Fund, a leading health research centre, has recently noted that on past trends, public health and social care could eventually consume nearly 20% of the UK’s total wealth (the current figure is 8%).

If we don’t change the ways that public services are shaped and delivered, the choices could be stark: higher taxes, chronically underfunded health and social care or deep cuts in other important services.

Nor are these the only challenges. Researchers warn that tax and welfare changes will result in higher levels of child and family poverty in Wales. Together with shifting demographics, this will have a big impact on demand for housing. Flood risk and other effects of climate change are increasing. Across the board, people’s expectations of service quality and availability are changing rapidly, mobile technology and social media are revolutionising communications and possibilities.

Two kinds of reaction open to us all.

One option is to dig in, rely on cutting budgets year-on-year and hope for something to turn up. The result is likely to be demoralised and increasingly patchy services. The second option is to try to rethink and seek to transform our public services.

As a contribution to this debate, the independent Wales Public Services 2025 programme, hosted by Cardiff Business School, is investigating some of the long-term issues and possible solutions. This week, it is launching the first in a series of reports, in partnership with Nesta, the UK innovation foundation, and Carnegie UK, at the SOLACE (local authority chief executives) Wales conference.

Our work with Nesta argues for a quantum shift in the level of innovation in Welsh public services. Geoff Mulgan, Nesta’s chief executive, will make the case that Wales, as a small country with a proud history and strong sense of shared values, is well-placed to pioneer a country-wide approach to public innovation that could make an impact beyond its borders.

Wales has a good record of public innovation – after all it was the cradle of the NHS. But local innovations aren’t always picked up and adopted nationally. We need more innovation in the way services work together to tackle some of the big challenges facing Wales and in the way they interact with the public. The report celebrates innovative projects - for example in early years, supporting young people into work, crime prevention and enabling older people to live independently – but argues that we need to be much more ambitious to make the most of these existing innovations and to stimulate and test new ones.

This requires a step-change in the levels of engagement between government at all levels, researchers and innovators (including front-line staff and communities). Public service leaders need to see innovation as a vital part of their role. We need to find ways to mobilise the capacity of civil society and the private sector, and financing and incentivising public innovation in a more strategic way.

Wales is not alone in facing these pressures. Our second report, produced in partnership with Carnegie UK, looks at how six other small countries are responding. There are inspiring examples of innovation and good practice to draw on – whether rethinking relationships between citizens and local government in Molenwaard in The Netherlands or co-operative models of care for older people in Quebec or the Early Years Collaborative in Scotland focussing on outcomes for vulnerable children. Wales is already doing good work in many such areas. It is not that Wales has missed the boat – but it must become a brilliant learner from the experience of others.

The future direction of public services poses a big challenge for government at all levels and for civil society, the public has to be involved in the change programme which will be needed. The establishment of the Commission signals a wish to tackle the difficult questions, its findings cannot come too soon.

Wales – A Public Services Laboratory?

Matthew Gatehouse, co-author of ‘State of Innovation: Wales Public Services and the Challenge of Change’ asks whether the high proportion of Wales’ economic output attributable to public services, often seen as a weakness, could offer the nation a real advantage as the potential home to a cluster of innovative public services?

It’s widely accepted that industry clusters – loose geographical concentrations of firms from the same sector - can serve as catalysts for economic growth. Proximity leads to exchange of information, talent and supply chains among competing firms, Celebrated examples - life sciences in Cambridge and software in Silicon Valley - are well known throughout the world as hot-beds of innovation in their respective industries.

Would something similar be possible for public services? A close knit community of social scientists working with front-line practitioners from councils, health authorities and blue light services, capitalising on the proximity principle, could share ideas, skills and data to prototype and evaluate new public service models that focus on improved outcomes. Once these have been rigorously tested and proved to work they can be grown, scaled and replicated across whole systems.

The report that I’ve written with Adam Price for Nesta and the Wales Public Services 2025 Programme argues that a greater drive is needed to embed innovation in public services, and this small nation of 3 million people could be the ideal test bed for a radically different approach. Public services in Wales – like the rest of the UK - are facing a combination of financial cuts and rising demand. Left unchecked our current approach could lead to an increasing proportion of national income being consumed by health and social care alone - leaving little for other local services.

When researching the report we were looking for disruptive solutions that could radically change the sector - just think about Wikipedia’s impact on the printed encyclopaedia or Napster’s impact on CDs. There is a widely held view that public services are not that good at delivering the radically different solutions that that we have come to expect from other sectors yet Wales, a nation with a strong tradition of mutualism, has a distinguished history as a power-house of public innovation. The models for the NHS and for locally accountable education authority were first minted here.

The potential remains for Wales to play a significant role developing different ways of meeting needs -and not just inside its own borders. It has, in relative terms, an economy dominated by public services, effectively forming an industry cluster; it has a strong social science research base and crucially as a small nation it is the ideal size to scale new ideas beyond the local, without losing focus or agility.

In short Wales has the potential to become a global test-bed for the public services of the future.

‘State of Innovation: Wales Public Services and the Challenge of Change’, from Nesta and Wales Public Services 2025, will be launched on Friday 10th May.

Weathering the Storm: A look at small countries’ public services in time of austerity

The State of Innovation is a report by the philanthropic organisation, Carnegie UK Trust in partnership with the Wales Public Services 2025 programme.

The report reviews how other small countries - Austria, Denmark, the Netherlands, Quebec, Scotland and New Zealand - have responded positively to the ‘perfect storm’ challenge. For example, rethinking relationships between citizens and local government in Molenwaard in the Netherlands or the Early Years Collaborative in Scotland focussing on outcomes for vulnerable children

Report Summaries:

Weathering the Storm? A look at small countries’ public services in times of austerity (summary)

Dod drwy’r gwaethaf? Golwg ar wasanaeth cyhoeddus gwledydd bychain mewn cyfnod o lymder (Crynodeb)

Full report (only available in English)

Weathering the storm? A look at small countries’ public services in time of austerity

State of Innovation: Welsh Public Services and the Challenge of Change

The State of Innovation is a report by the UK innovation foundation, Nesta in partnership with the Wales Public Services 2025 programme.

The report reviews public innovation in Wales and argues that the transition from individual innovations to action which transforms services across Wales requires a series of step-changes. These include strenthening the relationship between innovators, researchers and all levels of government; ensuring that public service leaders see innovation as core to delivery; making the best use of the contribution from civil society and the private sector, and financing public innovation in a more strategic way.

Full report:

State of Innovation: Welsh Public Services and Challenge of Change

Oes Arloesi: Gwasanaethau Cyhoeddus Cymru A Her Newid

SOLACE Wales conference 2013

The SOLACE Public Services Conference is Wales’ essential event of the year for Chief Executives and senior managers in Welsh public service.

The theme for this year’s conference is Austerity - Change - Opportunity and features a keynote speech by Derek Jones, Permanent Secretary of the Welsh Government.

The economic, demographic, social and environmental pressures facing Wales in the longer-term have called into question many of the assumptions that underpin public service delivery. But we are in a unique position to mould an emerging Welsh public service model that will be sustainable in the face of prolonged economic and demographic pressure.

The Director of Wales Public Services 2025, Michael Trickey, will be speaking at the conference. Two reports will be launched.

For more information about the conference please see the Solace website at http://www.solace.org.uk/wales2013/index.htm

Steering Group meeting, 8 May 2013

The next meeting of the Steering group will be on the 8 May 2013, at 6pm to 7.30pm at the Cardiff Business School.

Steering Group meeting, 17 April 2013

The next meeting of the Steering group will be on the 17 April 2013, at 10am to 12pm at the Cardiff Business School.